Last Updated:
September 29, 2006

Local rescue shelter struggles with overpopulation
Sean Comstock, posted Sept. 28, 2006

With the recent disease outbreak at the Carthage Humane Society resulting in the untimely death of 74 dogs according to the Missouri Department of Agriculture, the public eye is once again witness to the severely overpopulated and under-funded conditions many animal shelters are currently experiencing. The American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals reports that within the United States, there are roughly 5,000 operating animal shelters. However, with no national organization appointed to the monitoring of these shelters, it is virtually impossible to ensure that all of these operations are in compliance with the federal mandates of animal care and handling.

Overpopulation is a constant problem in many open shelters across the U.S. Open shelters differ from private ones in that they accept any animal that is surrendered to them including strays. The Central Missouri Humane Society is the only operating open shelter in the Columbia area. The shelter accepts animals from 20 different municipalities in the mid-Missouri area. This causes a frequent surplus in numbers and an increased threat of disease outbreak according CMHS Shelter Relation Coordinator Heather Duren.

The increasing population at the CMHS consequently entails more animals being euthanized. The veterinarians at the CMHS base their decision to euthanize on the health and temperament of the animal. There exists no set quota that the shelter must abide by in terms of population due in large part to the constant stream of animals that arrive daily. At the end of the day, the shelter must have a certain amount of empty spaces capable of housing the drop-offs for the following day.

According to ASPCA, nearly eight to twelve million pets are admitted to animal shelters each year nationwide. Of these, approximately five to nine million are euthanized. “You can only protect so many animals to a certain degree from getting diseases,” Duren said. While no stray or untested animals are kept in the same cage, there is no definite method of ensuring an environment free from disease when dealing with excessive numbers and easily transmitted diseases.

The incident in Carthage was due to an outbreak of Parvo. Parvo is a deadly viral disease found in dogs that attacks the inner-lining of their digestive system, killing white blood cells said Janet Tobiassen Crosby, DVM. Duren said what happened in Carthage is nothing unique as incidents like this are all too common. “It could really happen anywhere,” Duren said.

{back to homepage}